Screenshots or an exported PDF: which is better for text messages in court?

An exported PDF is usually better: it holds the whole conversation with the exact date, time and sender's number on every message, and pages that can be numbered, while screenshots show only what was on screen and are easier to challenge as cropped or edited. Screenshots can be enough for a few short messages in an informal hearing; for anything contested, export the thread.

Updated November 18, 2026 · Not legal advice

Side by side

ScreenshotsExported PDF (Exhibit)
Time on every messageOnly at time breaksYes, with time zone
Sender's phone numberOften only a contact nameYes, for iMessage, SMS and most sources
Whole conversationOnly what you capturedEvery message in the range
Edits and unsent messagesOnly what you open and capture on screenOriginal text and times, when Messages recorded them
Page and Bates numbersNoYes
Shows the file wasn't changed laterNoSHA-256 verification page
CostFree$19.99 once

Exhibit for Mac turns the conversation into a PDF you can file: exact times, read receipts, edits, Bates numbers. $19.99 once, no subscription, 7-day refund.

When screenshots are enough

A handful of messages, in a hearing where the other side doesn't dispute them. Make sure each screenshot shows the contact's number, the date and the time.

When to export

Long threads, disputed messages, edits, or anything a lawyer or judge will read closely. See authenticating text messages and are screenshots admissible?.

General information, not legal advice. Ask the court clerk, a self-help center or a lawyer what your court expects.

Questions

Can the other side say I edited a screenshot?

They can, and a screenshot alone can't show otherwise. An export with a hash and the original phone or backup kept makes that harder.